Barnet to quit Underhill RSS Feed


Barnet FC addresses fans exclusively through the Times Series

Dennis Signy, who was recently awarded a BBC Sport lifetime achievement award. Dennis Signy, who was recently awarded a BBC Sport lifetime achievement award.

By Dennis Signy, appointed an OBE in 1983 for his community and charity work in the borough of Barnet

Seven decades ago I had my introduction to Underhill and watched Lester Finch, surely the greatest player in Barnet's history, in action.

In the past decade, as PR consultant to chairman Tony Kleanthous, I have been by his side in talks with Barnet Council about the Bees getting a site for a new stadium in the borough.

I guess I have earned my two bob's worth of say about the ground where the club has played for 104 years.

Over the past 17 years Tony Kleanthous has put his personal fortune and health on the line in Barnet's cause.

The fans who have chanted that he's the best chairman in the land know he has the interests of the club at heart but I can vouch for the total hostility towards our football club from various officers and members of the council since we tried to establish a South Underhill stadium on the present cricket club site.

Janet Matthewson, who vigorously ran a Keep Barnet Alive campaign for four years, can chronicle wide evidence of obstruction from the town hall over the years. Surely supporters recall the battles the KBA encountered.

When the KBA was disbanded, there was a commitment from the council to work with the club to ensure its long term future in the borough. Has that been fulfilled ? - No.

Tony Kleanthous produced two Working Together documents - they never caught on with the worthies at the town hall.

The Times series launched a campaign,Backing the Bees, but, apart from a few hollow words of support from some politicians at election time that fell away, nothing moves forward for li'l ol' Barnet at our town hall.

What is not taken into account is the great work Janet Matthewson, who now runs the Barnet FC Community Trust, and her team achieve around the borough in delivering projects and helping to create a safer stronger community. They engage thousands of young people working with youth offending and help with health, education, anti-knife crime and personal safety ... working with young and old in mental health at secure units and old people's homes.

A community football club is more than just a squad of blokes kicking a ball around.

By the way, we also give away thusands of tickets to local schoolchildren and disadvantaged groups to encourage an interest in sport.

The issue today is clearcut.

The current lease on the cricket club expires next December, allowing for the purchase of an extension for 125 years at a peppercorn rent.

The council have countered by offering 15 years at what they consider market value, nearly four times what the club is presently paying.

In addition, after years of unrestricted use of Priory Grove, the road used by cars to access the ground and car parking facilities, the council decided to try and levy a charge to allow vehicular acess to continue.

The Scouts and St John Ambulance, who also have sites in Priory Grove, do not have to pay.

These issues are not sudden. They have been rumbling on for years.

So Barnet FC asked the Football League if they could start next season at Underhill even though the cricket club lease expires half way through the season and the club could not guarantee that they could finish there after December.

The League said that guarantees were needed.

The truth is that Barnet has only a short term future at Underhill anyway.

We are in danger of becoming second class citizens as our rivals move to 21st Century accomodation and increase their revenues.

Tony Kleanthous has spent nearly £2 million in the last few years on ground improvements, getting a new South Stand and floodlights, but the Bees still lag behind. The club directors years ago, faced with the council's hostility, discussed a move away.

Woolwich Arsenal didn't do badly switching from South to North across the Thames and now the Emirates did they?

The big question is: whither now? There is no ready answer at this stage.

Until the letter from the Football League Tony Kleanthous was thinking of staying at Underhill for a few more seasons. There was no Plan B on his immediate agenda.

It will be a wrench for all at Barnet to leave the spiritual home.

But there is little point wasting more time hoping for a new site from a council that wants a ridiculously high market value for a lease for the cricket club but lets Saracens RFC have Copthall for nothing.

It is patently obvious Barnet Council does not see us as a community asset.

Comments(11)

Mr unreasonable and always looking for fault says...
6:02pm Wed 21 Dec 11

What a surprise - the Times publishes an anti-council article by a former employee of Barnet FC expressing misinformed opinions!!

The club can easily continue to operate at the site on the terms offered by the council. And Saracens are not getting Copthall for nothing - £10million investment - Barnet FC simply cannot match it!

Don't Call Me Dave says...
10:12pm Wed 21 Dec 11

Nobody can question Mr Signy’s loyalty to Barnet Football Club but, as usual, the facts of the matter cloud his judgment. The lease to the cricket club expires next year. They do have a legal right to a new lease, but not on the same terms. They are entitled to a much shorter lease at open market value.

If Mr Kleanthous thinks they are entitled to another 125 years at a peppercorn rent, he can apply to the Court for a Judge to set the terms of the lease. Good luck with that attempt to make legal history.

Granting another long lease at a peppercorn rent (without the payment of a substantial premium) would not comply with s.123 Local Government Act 1972. The council has already broken this law once in its dealings with the football club. To do so a second time would be unconscionable.

Mr Signy complains that the Scouts and St John Ambulance do not have to pay for access to Priory Grove. Nor should they have to - they are voluntary organisations, unlike Barnet Football Club. If Mr Kleanthous really believes that the club is a community asset, he could demonstrate it by returning the ownership of the freehold of the stadium back to the public, from whom it was sold secretly by the last Labour Administration.

chris stevens says...
12:48am Thu 22 Dec 11

We can negotiate a 3, 4 or 5 years extension on the lease at market value while we build the new Hive stadium.............
... simples!
Bee Army :-)

Nickyisgod says...
5:08am Thu 22 Dec 11

Mr unreasonable and always looking for fault wrote:
What a surprise - the Times publishes an anti-council article by a former employee of Barnet FC expressing misinformed opinions!!

The club can easily continue to operate at the site on the terms offered by the council. And Saracens are not getting Copthall for nothing - £10million investment - Barnet FC simply cannot match it!
How do you know they can't match it? The first BFC knew about Saracens being parachuted into Copthall by the council was when it was announced in the press.

Watch the club raise and invest that money outside of the Borough. Driven out by an apathetic Council.

Still, at least the community in Harrow will benefit from it. Nice one.

Nickyisgod says...
5:09am Thu 22 Dec 11

How do you know they can't match it? The first BFC knew about Saracens being parachuted into Copthall by the council was when it was announced in the press.

Watch the club raise and invest that money outside of the Borough. Driven out by an apathetic Council.

Still, at least the community in Harrow will benefit from it. Nice one.

redrenault says...
8:07am Thu 22 Dec 11

It absolutely stinks.. 99 year lease for saracens ? for £1..its pathetic. Even if the council approve it that is not the end and I am sure it will be a while before they actually play their first game - if ever. Football at the copthall site only has a 1 year lease as do other users .. who is going to invest in anything with such a short term ? The councillors are pathetic . and the Mill Hill preservation society .. not fit for purpose. The Chairman likes rugby so despite having cash in the bank seems to refuse to life a finger...

MichaelH says...
9:06am Thu 22 Dec 11

Perhaps Don't Call Me Dave could elaborate as to why a long lease with peppercorn rent for Saracens at Copthall is perfectly OK, but one for Barnet FC for the cricket club land would be a breach of his beloved Local Government Act 1972?

Don't Call Me Dave says...
11:58am Thu 22 Dec 11

Michael

I am not aware of the details of the Saracens transaction, but if they have been granted a 99 year lease at a peppercorn rent without paying a premium then I would have thought it unlikely that the transaction could comply with s.123 Local Government Act 1972, and it should be challenged on that basis.

exiledgeordie says...
8:27pm Fri 23 Dec 11

I played for Barnet F C back in the late 1950's and the council were trying to get rid of us then, so nothing has changed for 50 odd years. With people like that obnoxious Coleman sitting in the hot seat BFC will get no change out of the council. The tory council want BFC and the cricket club out so that they can build more houses/flats to produce more council tax, and turn Barnet playing fields into one new big housing estate just like Dollis Valley.

chris stevens says...
1:43pm Sat 24 Dec 11

Footballers playing at politics?! Whatever next - we'll never have Barnet politicians playing at football, will we?
As for "Barnet playing fields into one new big housing estate just like Dollis Valley" that'll make a lot of money for whoever owns the land.
I wonder who that might be ?:-)
Stand up and take a bow Tony, you finally got us out of Underhill so you can develop the site just like you always wanted.
COYB, Lawrie for Chairman!!

james smyth says...
12:18am Tue 10 Jan 12

Maybe they should make it a theatre.....every game is a pantomime!

click2find

Most popular






About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree